ZiNgA BuRgA Wrote:I'm not sure what happened to the previous discussion, but meh, if you just happen to like everything, then I can't see any fault in rating everything high. You just need to scale your ratings a little, that's it.
I think Senseito Sakura maybe should increase the spread a little, but that's his choice, and sometimes, it's really difficult to say whether one is better than the other.......
oh lawd, how can I like everything!?!?!?
its not like I have 8+ ratings for everything on the list!
do I have to repeat myself that I've been lucky enough to have seen some very good anime during the time I've watched Anime??
If any of you want to recommend any bad Anime just for the Balance of the Universe, tell me some. I'll watch them just for the sake of it.
You're misunderstanding him. He means to just spread your ratings a bit. (i.e. more variance, rather than all clumping on 8, 9 and 10). He's not telling you to dislike stuff.
I wouldn't spread my ratings if was going to make them inaccurate, they are as accurate as they ever have been at this point.
I'd like to see if someone can discuss a rating I have given to an Anime, that they think is overrated.
If then, they point at a flaw that I can agree on, THEN I will decrease my rating of it.
Quote:This List has one purpose ~ to provide mini-(p)reviews of Anime Series to anyone who would like to know about them and to help them to decide whether or not he/she/it wants to see it!
Senseito Sakura Wrote:I'd like to see if someone can discuss a rating I have given to an Anime, that they think is overrated.
If then, they point at a flaw that I can agree on, THEN I will decrease my rating of it.
It doesn't work that way, because ratings are subjective.
As an example, I previously argued that the Elfen Lied ending sucks. You think it rocks. I thought the kiminozo ending rocks. You thought it sucks. Wee both had our reasons. Now who is correct? Noone. It's all subjective depending on the view of the reviewer.
There is no absolute "this sucks". It's like asking "do apples taste nice"... well, it depends on the person eating it. There's no definite "yes" or "no" for that question. (It's just that most people would probably say "yes", so if you say "no", you're in the minority group, which is the case wth rating stuff too high).
So I have been arguing the whole time, (spanning like 5 different arguments) that you are optimistic, and tend to think stuff more on the good side than the bad side, and tend to like stuff more than the average person.
You say "I've been lucky enough to have seen some very good anime during the time I've watched Anime" I say it's more accurately "I'm lucky enough to enjoy most of the anime I've watched, though others might not have, for the same anime".
I haven't seen the majority of stuff you've seen.
But if you really want some examples,
Spoiler:
Da Capo. You gave it a 9/10. I would give like 6/10 (7 at most). I found it to be nothing special. The storyline was not that strong, and a whole lot of episodes were just fillers, and not important to the story. Like wooo, lets do this, next, wooo, lets do that. (Some people like that style, I don't particularly). I don't particularly like the character models that much either. Mainly though, the storyline isn't strong enough.
Elfen Lied is not 10/10. Ending sucked. (I don't want to argue more with you on that. Had like 2 arguments on that too)
Rozen Maiden < 8/10. Meh, just didn't like it. Lots of reasons, like with Da Capo. Won't bother listing all of them, but mainly, story=weak. 6/10 at most 7.
I haven't completely finished watching Shana yet, but so far (1/2 ay), it just seems like stereotypical stuff. Nothing special. Not 9 worthy (of course, I haven't seen whole thing yet, so my impression could possibly change).
Seen a bit of True Tears... And for this one, I must say it's worth more than 6/10. (Omg, I'm saying you under-rated something!!!) But again, I haven't seen the whole thing yet.
So that is a worthy conclusion ~ trying to analyse my ratings is completely pointless because you have your own opinion!
Assassinator Wrote:You say "I've been lucky enough to have seen some very good anime during the time I've watched Anime" I say it's more accurately "I'm lucky enough to enjoy most of the anime I've watched, though others might not have, for the same anime".
Well you have your opinion on my list, I just find it irritating because that statement is wrong. Oh well.
Assassinator Wrote:Da Capo. You gave it a 9/10. I would give like 6/10 (7 at most). I found it to be nothing special. The storyline was not that strong, and a whole lot of episodes were just fillers, and not important to the story. Like wooo, lets do this, next, wooo, lets do that. (Some people like that style, I don't particularly). I don't particularly like the character models that much either. Mainly though, the storyline isn't strong enough.
I saw no fillers.
Assassinator Wrote:Elfen Lied is not 10/10. Ending sucked. (I don't want to argue more with you on that. Had like 2 arguments on that too)
Yeah..... lol
Assassinator Wrote:Rozen Maiden < 8/10. Meh, just didn't like it. Lots of reasons, like with Da Capo. Won't bother listing all of them, but mainly, story=weak. 6/10 at most 7.
Wee just have different likes for that kinda story, hehe
Assassinator Wrote:I haven't completely finished watching Shana yet, but so far (1/2 ay), it just seems like stereotypical stuff. Nothing special. Not 9 worthy (of course, I haven't seen whole thing yet, so my impression could possibly change).
Stereotypical or not, Shana is fantastic.
Assassinator Wrote:Seen a bit of True Tears... And for this one, I must say it's worth more than 6/10. (Omg, I'm saying you under-rated something!!!) But again, I haven't seen the whole thing yet.
Senseito Sakura Wrote:So that is a worthy conclusion ~ trying to analyse my ratings is completely pointless because you have your own opinion!
Trying to analyse how much you enjoy stuff is pointless.
Trying to analyse how you rate stuff is not pointless. Same level of enjoyment doesn't mean same ratings. (You enjoying stuff more could be one reason, but there could also be the reason that you simply overrate). And there's also the variance factor as Zinga mentioned (and I mentioned in the past).
Senseito Sakura Wrote:Well you have your opinion on my list, I just find it irritating because that statement is wrong. Oh well.
My statement or yours.
Senseito Sakura Wrote:I saw no fillers.
Reword: stuff that doesn't really add to the story and/or isn't relevant. If you take it out, you'd not really notice. Unlike for example, Elfen Lied, for which if you take an episode out, it leaves you with a big knowledge gap.
Senseito Sakura Wrote:Stereotypical or not, Shana is fantastic.
Wait till I finish. I'll decide then.
Senseito Sakura Wrote:You know you shouldn't be making an opinion yet
Yes, that's why I said » (of course, I haven't seen whole thing yet, so my impression could possibly change).
Senseito Sakura Wrote:So that is a worthy conclusion ~ trying to analyse my ratings is completely pointless because you have your own opinion!
Trying to analyse how much you enjoy stuff is pointless.
Trying to analyse how you rate stuff is not pointless. Same level of enjoyment doesn't mean same ratings. (You enjoying stuff more could be one reason, but there could also be the reason that you simply overrate). And there's also the variance factor as Zinga mentioned (and I mentioned in the past).
Perhaps it'd be easier to interpret if I just went for a 5-Star system.
Assassinator Wrote:
Senseito Sakura Wrote:I saw no fillers.
Reword: stuff that doesn't really add to the story and/or isn't relevant. If you take it out, you'd not really notice. Unlike for example, Elfen Lied, for which if you take an episode out, it leaves you with a big knowledge gap.
I clearly saw Da Capo in a different light ^^
Assassinator Wrote:
Senseito Sakura Wrote:Stereotypical or not, Shana is fantastic.
Senseito Sakura Wrote:Perhaps it'd be easier to interpret if I just went for a 5-Star system.
What difference would that make? now it's out of 10. After translating to the stars system, it's still out of 10 (you can use 1/2 star). So effectively the same thing.
So instead of people complaining that you have too many 10/10s, people will complain that you have too many 5 stars.
Clannad, ef - a tale of memories, Elfen Lied, (I'm going to decrease Hanbu No Tsuki Ga Noboru Sora, that was definitely in the heat of the moment), Hokuto no Ken - Raoh Den Gekito no Sho, Kanon and Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei all totally deserve their ratings.
