^ Lol you should make your own thread some time...
Chuunibyou demo Koi ga chocolateai!
Nicely done comedy/romance. I quite liked the unique idea of mixing in an odd personality trait and how it was handled. The more serious parts didn't quite work so well for me though. For me, the biggest issue would be the ending - I found it difficult to swallow. Nonetheless, a good balance of comedy and romance kept throughout the show.
3.5 stars, would've been 4 if I liked the ending more
Ore no Kanojo
Nice to watch after Chuunibyou, which helped give a bit of context on this one. Apart from the fact that this show involves chuunibyou, it isn't that similar. I enjoyed the start and end, but not so much the middle (although it was still amusing quite often). I'd say this is somewhat more of a comedy than something to be considered more seriously.
3 stars
Spoiler:
Well, since I did one after episode 4, I might as well finish this off. Episode 4 was a nice turning point, ep6 probably was one too, but was too soon after ep4.
I have to say, I don't really like the two new characters - they're pushing the harem aspect too much and don't seem to offer anything in the realm of uniqueness.
Mana (Masuzu's sister) is an interesting one. I suppose it's coming off the idea that rich people are sometimes rather unsympathetic, and she seems to act like that. Masuzu seems to have a number of similarities, but is more refined (but cares more about others than her sister) whilst Mana just comes off as obnoxious.
I had expected that Masuzu's relationship with the rest of her family would be the climax of the story, but it didn't turn out that way.
Though Mana's personality seems to have changed dramatically in episode 12 - presumably she realised the stuff Masuzu was going through and became more sympathetic?
One also does wonder what happens after the story with this relationship.
Himeka seemed to promote the idea that 8th grade syndrome is a wonderful thing, similar to what Masuzu seemed to be doing. Otherwise uninteresting character.
I didn't get why Kaoru was trying to push Ai onto Eita when he knows that Eita is in a relationship with masuzu and Chiwa. Kaoru didn't get much attention in the show, but he was always shown as some considerate guy who listens into Eita's problems. Perhaps he thought Eita was no longer 'anti-love'?
So, to go back to my previous post:
- Both Eita & Masuzu started out hating love relationships, but seem to have changed by the end; interesting way to conclude the show To be honest
- In regards to the show promoting the idea that most love relationships are shallow, it still seems to show the idea, somewhat in a self parodising way (Himeka and Ai's attraction don't seem particularly deep). However it does also suggest that it's not take lightly, a number of times, eg Ai's fake relationship, Masuzu becomming less sure of herself when she gets closer to Eita, or the seriousness in the final few episodes; perhaps suggesting that love can come in various forms, such as a common interest against 'normal love', as opposed to the stereotypical childhood friend thingy
- Masuzu's use of the notebook: hard to say if there's some deeper purpose. It's clear that she, along with the other girls, do take an interest in it, and Masuzu, at the very least, used it merely for her own entertainment purposes.
Baka to Test
Liked the idea. Fun show, a little dreary in the middle. A bit repetitive at times, but not a big issue IMO. I think the creators did a decent job at achieving their goal.
The specials are good.
3 stars
School Days
Had watched the first episode a few years back, found it boring, but decided to press through this time. Starts off kinda boring, gets more interesting towards the middle. In fact it kinda had the same vibe as KgNE for a while.
But of course, the ending was pure awesome and itself made the show worthwhile.
It's an interesting (different) way to do the more typical harem show.
On a more serious note though, it was difficult to follow the thoughts of the characters a number of times. I tried to understand their motives, and think I can generally follow their thoughts, but they tend to do various things that seem out of personality. Granted, it's 12 episodes and they probably didn't want to go to too much effort in the ways of explanations, but when characters seemingly act against their personality, it gets hard to swallow. Also the way that they've arranged events and characters seems a little too artificial.
3.5 stars
Spoiler:
Probably the main thing I wonder about: did Sekai actually get pregnant or was Kotonoha correct? I really believed the former (and still do), but there seems to be a number of hints around the place that the latter could actually be feasible.
Also, black blood? Is this meant to be symbolic or something? I can guess Sekai's might've been just the lighting, but Makoto's was just weird.
I'm not sure if it's just me, but is a high schooler living alone a common thing in anime?
The second Nanoha movie is more or less what's to be expected, as it's basically a summary of the second season. Unlike the first movie, they didn't add any side stories, so it's just a condensed and slightly changed version of the second season, with, of course, lots of glitzy effects (which is why you'd watch the movie in the first place, right?).
Ore no Imouto S2 seems to be more comedy focused than the S1 - looking forward to see how it goes.
(This post was last modified: 28/04/2013 10:00 PM by ZiNgA BuRgA.)
Chuunibyou demo Koi ga chocolateai was pretty good, drama didn't sit right with me but it wasn't completely horrible
Ore no Kanojo
Spoiler:
It was entertaining but that ending.. was it a harem ending? Call me crazy but I was hoping a one girl ending but this was a harem anime from the start.
School Days
Spoiler:
Quote:Also, black blood? Is this meant to be symbolic or something? I can guess Sekai's might've been just the lighting, but Makoto's was just weird.
I thought it was just censorship especially after what happened with that murder that caused them to postpone the episode.
Eita's aunt classifies the ending as either a harem or warzone. Due to the show seemingly promoting the idea that ordinary relationships are uninteresting (or perhaps that relationships shouldn't simply be classed into categories), I'd say that the ending fits neither of the categories.
After all, Eita's aunt failed to understand Eita's relationship with Masuzu - she did pick up on the fake part, but failed to see beyond that.
It's interesting to note that the aunt said that, for:
- harem ending - have to manage flags
- warzone ending - have to pick one person
Eita seemingly picked Masuzu, tried to ditch Himeka and Ai, but didn't seem to try to get rid of Chiwa. He visited her, as if he wanted to, but otherwise didn't seem to have much of a plan.
In a sense, he got both 'endings', but for the wrong reasons:
- he got the harem, because of flag mismanagement
- he got the warzone because he couldn't decisively pick between Masuzu and Chiwa
So in short, IMO, it's a bit of both.
Spoiler for School Days:
Interesting, although censoring by making the blood black doesn't seem like much censoring. They did mute any voices at that point though...
I just read that apparently a daughter murdered her father, caused the delay of the last episode... interesting to know.
(This post was last modified: 29/04/2013 04:57 PM by ZiNgA BuRgA.)
(28/04/2013 09:52 PM)ZiNgA BuRgA Wrote: ^ Lol you should make your own thread some time...
That would have been a good idea 2 years ago. Nowadays I don't really even watch anime.
(28/04/2013 09:52 PM)ZiNgA BuRgA Wrote: School Days
....
But of course, the ending was pure awesome and itself made the show worthwhile.
I wasn't particularly amused by the ending.
(28/04/2013 09:52 PM)ZiNgA BuRgA Wrote: Also, black blood?
Wait you downloaded the TV rips instead of the DVD rips?
(28/04/2013 09:52 PM)ZiNgA BuRgA Wrote: In fact it kinda had the same vibe as KgNE for a while.
Watch White Album 2 when it comes out later this year, it has a very similar vibe to KgNE.
WA2 is pretty much the highest rated eroge at the moment, with a 95 median and stuff. If they do the anime properly it should be good. However WA2 is structured into something like a short 0.5MB Introductory Chapter and a very long 3.8MB Closing Chapter where the bulk of the story happens. Don't really know how the anime would work around that, hopefully they don't try to drag the Intro Chapter into 12 episodes as that would be terrible.
09/05/2013 10:02 AM
ZiNgA BuRgA
Smart Alternative
Posts: 17,022.2988 Threads: 1,174
Joined: 19th Jan 2007
Reputation: -1.71391 E-Pigs: 446.1274
Kotonoha no Niwa has some damn awesome artwork. Not a big fan of the story, but seems to be done alright, and not bad in hindsight for a 45 minute film.
Similar-ish in a number of ways to 5cm/s
11/06/2013 08:23 PM
ZiNgA BuRgA
Smart Alternative
Posts: 17,022.2988 Threads: 1,174
Joined: 19th Jan 2007
Reputation: -1.71391 E-Pigs: 446.1274
OreImo S2 is more enjoyable than S1.
Kirino becomes more dere, characters in general a bit more fun. Not quite so sure about episodes 11 & 12 - perhaps they're setting up for the additional 3 episodes...
13/07/2013 02:42 AM
ZiNgA BuRgA
Smart Alternative
Posts: 17,022.2988 Threads: 1,174
Joined: 19th Jan 2007
Reputation: -1.71391 E-Pigs: 446.1274
The 2 Madoka movies are basically a retelling of the TV series with minimal changes.
As such, I'd say they're a viable alternative to watching the TV series, although they're about the same length.
The artwork, in the places that they've changed them, does look nicer.