Poll: Whats your favorite?

S7* · 13/05/2010 02:22 AM

You know what to do folks - vote for your favorite sig!

Good luck to both of you!

dSmoove · 13/05/2010 03:10 AM

I voted for the first one. It has a nice flow to it.

rockhead · 13/05/2010 06:09 AM

voted for the first one both are very nice though

1-R · 13/05/2010 07:53 AM

hooray!! one vote!♥

eKusoshisut0 · 13/05/2010 09:08 AM

LOL, If that bottom one is yours Lunar, I think I am the only one who has voted for it....so far 

diego · 13/05/2010 09:14 AM

Wow.

I am REALLY surprised by how this is turning out.

SkyDX · 13/05/2010 10:38 AM

Voted for Lunar, Diegos is well made but there's something weired about it I can't put my finger on...^^'

1-R · 13/05/2010 10:39 AM

(13/05/2010 10:38 AM)SkyDX Wrote: Voted for Lunar, Diegos is well made but there's something weired about it I can't put my finger on...^^'

Skyy-kun♥

Tetris999 · 13/05/2010 10:53 AM

Meh, usually a "real life" stock sig has a lot of potential to own anything else because it has that sense of depth to it, but i don't know about here. I felt that lunar's (inb4 he's voting jus cause it's leik anime) anime sig had a lot more of a sharp feel to it; though it lacked depth it had a concise style that played out well; the colors and lighting work a ok as well.

I can tell deigo had a lot more skill put in, but there's just a conflicting factor between the colors, it looks like you're forcing that purple away and making everything orange; i know what you would be getting at but it's not integrating well. Also, I'm personally not a fan of that noise effect that you used for the background, totally not smooth (>_>). Everything was a tad blurry as well, when i would assume since you would have such a good amount of depth to the render you would be able to play around with it and that's where it falls flat, but it's totally great anyway; point is, lunar executed his medium just how it was supposed to work, that's why i voted for him.

 But deigo is winning so meh xD

S7* · 13/05/2010 11:12 AM

well said diego.

I personally can't pick one of the two at the moment... neither are your best efforts - but they are certainly not bad either.

With diegos, the basic style used for HITGIRL works unusually.... I can't tell whether its her or the background that doesn't quite fit... but as usual the work is classy and a pleasure to look at and take in - for good and bad as it would rise questions about some of the things used in the sig.. even if it was just for looks.

As for Lunars its quite simplistic, but its his trademark eye-catching flare he usually has in his sigs that works... while the text (TOMOYO KICK) seems cheap and probably not thought about for long because it shouldn't be there at all. Also done himself a favor with keeping it quite small because he'd have to work harder then ;p

Well done you two, I look forward to seeing how this goes.

Poll: Whats your favorite? This poll is closed.
	13	46.43%
	15	53.57%
Total	28 votes	100%

Threaded Mode \| Linear Mode [VOTING] diego vs Lunar
Author	Message