assassinator Wrote:Yeah, Saya really isn't the kind of stuff to recommend to random people.  But if you can stand all the gore and the shit that happens, Saya's story is actually good (fucked up but good).  But you have to play to the end, the true ending, it's like bittersweet.

Am i the only one who felt that
was the good end?

Also that
All in all, i liked saya no uta, but i have to admit it was fudgeed up.

I can't stop thinking about how demented it is, and it's hard to distract myself away from the scenes of it. Not that totally I regret reading but in a way I wish I hadn't.

(04/03/2011 10:43 AM)eKusoshisut0 Wrote:  Which ending did you prefer?

True ending >>> early ending ≥ normal ending.

By the way, by the true end, I mean the "final gift" ending.  There should be little doubt about it being the true ending, and if you're still not convinced, that's the ending that plays the actual "Saya's Song".

(05/03/2011 06:03 AM)Tetris999 Wrote:  Am i the only one who felt that

Spoiler for Don't OPEN IF YOU Don't WANT TO GET SPOILED!!!:

Saya getting shot with a shot gun

was the good end?

For a lot of people, that would be the preferred end, and for even more people, it could be classified as the "good end".

I'm pretty sure Proper would feel that way for example, if he actually played that far, which I very much doubt.  What I don't doubt as much is that if Proper did actually get all the way to the end, he would rate the endings 2 > 1 > true.

If your dominant feeling is that Fuminori and Saya both need to be killed/put to justice, or if you're completely disgusted by the gore and other stuff (spoiler!), or if you simply just hate Saya (the character)...  then you probably won't see the beauty within the true ending.

(05/03/2011 06:03 AM)Tetris999 Wrote:  Also that

Spoiler for Don't DOOOOO IT!:

Rape scene made me feel kinda fucked up to read past, which is also confusing because since saya is an alien monster; how the hell did she get raped by a guy who she could easily kill?

(This post was last modified: 06/03/2011 12:51 AM by Assassinator.)

(06/03/2011 12:37 AM)Assassinator Wrote:  By the way, by the true end, I mean the "final gift" ending.  There should be little doubt about it being the true ending, and if you're still not convinced, that's the ending that plays the actual "Saya's Song".

Also, the lyrics and translations of, of the 2 songs can be found here...

http://atashi.wordpress.com/2007/10/13/s...-no-kutsu/
http://atashi.wordpress.com/2007/10/02/s...ya-no-uta/

The whole VN being named Saya's Song, it's definitely worthwhile to read through the lyrics of that song.  After you finish the true end.

(05/03/2011 06:03 AM)Tetris999 Wrote:  All in all, i liked saya no uta, but i have to admit it was fudgeed up.

Ok, here's my ratings of some select things based on these 2 criterion.

- A 0-10 scale of how dark, death, suffering and despair vs how bright, rainbows and ponies everything is (something like this)... and...
- A 0-10 scale of how messed up and disturbing something is (lower = more messed up)...

---

I'll grant you one wish, it can be anything.
So make a contract with me and become a magical girl!

All right, lets eat.
Ah! That's your wish? The magical girl is going to eat the mascot?
Ah! This one's no good, she doesn't understand the values humans have.

NGAAAAAA!!!
*chew*
*chew*

(This post was last modified: 10/04/2011 04:00 AM by Assassinator.)

(06/03/2011 02:38 AM)Assassinator Wrote:  I'll grant you one wish, it can be anything.
So make a contract with me and become a magical girl!

All right, lets eat.
Ah! That's your wish? The magical girl is going to eat the mascot?
Ah! This one's no good, she doesn't understand the values humans have.

NGAAAAAA!!!
*chew*
*chew*

O_o

(06/03/2011 02:38 AM)Assassinator Wrote:  Kimi ga Nozomu Eien (anime) = [5,8]

So, with anime in brackets. I just found out it was a VN today.