Goshi Wrote:Shingetsutan Tsukihime - The visual novel is good. The anime is bad. The art design is VASTLY inferior to the visual novel. The storyline strays away from the visual novel but turns into a mess. Taking many different elements from the novel and pasting them together, overall it made the storyline make little sense.

I actually liked that anime.

As for the storyline not following the VN, I watched the anime before playing the VN, so I wouldn't have picked it up back then. As for the storyline being a mess, yeah, there were some confusing bits, where more information was needed and everything.

I guess for someone who read the VN before the anime, the anime would seem like a complete disaster, since yeah, the story doesn't always follow, and isn't as crafted as well. But for someone who has not seen the VN, it's a good watch imo, although a bit confusing at times. (Well, at least that's my view. Most hardcore fans follow yours >_<)

As for the art... well, the VN doesn't have the best art either (don't like that art style that much). I liked the F/SN visual novel art style way more... + The VN has HORRIBLE HORRIBLE h-scenes. These aren't like normal h-scenes... degraded the VN many levels in my mind. Compared to other stuff I've seen, like Wind, tsukihime h-scenes are wtf-bad. Thankfully, the anime didn't include all that poo poo.

Type Moon is making a new VN I heard. Something to do with Aoko's past.

...

Some stuff I thought were real boring: Galaxy Angel, Excel Saga (I didn't like that style).

(This post was last modified: 09/04/2008 08:41 PM by Assassinator.)