So basically i want to get a new mp3 player (my nano 1st gen is working....but considering the fact its battery doesn't last long and ive taken it apart already to fix it; i think its smart to get rid of it right now)

So i went to check my local retailers and one of the shops offer to sell the zune for 100$ (4gb) if i trade in my old mp3 player! (im assuming i can trade in my nano for it by the way heh)

But then i see some reviews that the zune is good and bad compared to the apple ipod nano

but you see, that's 150$$ making it 50$$ more and i can't trade my mp3 player in

I don't know, logically the cheaper one should take the deal; but i don't want to buy a crappy player at that too

that's why i need your opinions