Goshi came up with this philosophy where all anime based off video games tend to suck including some VNs.

Not counting VNs I haven't watched many anime based off video games myself. In fact I can count exactly 3. Tales of Phantasia's anime, Tales of Symphonia's anime and Salamander. Salamander was amusing and it's been along time Tales of Phantasia so I can't remember it that well and I didn't like Symphonia's anime that much from the first ep (speaking of which, I've given up on a few animes just on the first ep, am I being fair enough?).

Now chances are I won't watch P4 only because I haven't played the game.