Senseito Sakura Wrote:I'd like to see if someone can discuss a rating I have given to an Anime, that they think is overrated.

If then, they point at a flaw that I can agree on, THEN I will decrease my rating of it.

It doesn't work that way, because ratings are subjective.

As an example, I previously argued that the Elfen Lied ending sucks. You think it rocks. I thought the kiminozo ending rocks. You thought it sucks. Wee both had our reasons. Now who is correct? Noone. It's all subjective depending on the view of the reviewer.

There is no absolute "this sucks". It's like asking "do apples taste nice"... well, it depends on the person eating it. There's no definite "yes" or "no" for that question. (It's just that most people would probably say "yes", so if you say "no", you're in the minority group, which is the case wth rating stuff too high).

---

So I have been arguing the whole time, (spanning like 5 different arguments) that you are optimistic, and tend to think stuff more on the good side than the bad side, and tend to like stuff more than the average person.

You say "I've been lucky enough to have seen some very good anime during the time I've watched Anime" I say it's more accurately "I'm lucky enough to enjoy most of the anime I've watched, though others might not have, for the same anime".

---

I haven't seen the majority of stuff you've seen.

But if you really want some examples,

(This post was last modified: 18/08/2008 02:50 AM by Assassinator.)