feinicks Wrote:Wee need remakes of and sequels to many anime.....

No, most anime are fine, at most needing a slightly better ending. I mean the bad anime are usually bad because of the story, so you can't really do anything about it. Changing the story would be changing everything.

Assassinator Wrote:Wee need Tsukihime remake. With Kara no Kyoukai graphics. Then it would be like the best anime ever.

If you're into vampires :P

Assassinator Wrote:No, most anime are fine, at most needing a slightly better ending. I mean the bad anime are usually bad because of the story, so you can't really do anything about it. Changing the story would be changing everything.

Firstly, does depend on how important you consider the story.  But you can change things a fair bit with only minor story modifications.  For example, the pacing, drama, emphasis etc can be tweaked to give a nicer effect on some shows I've seen.

ZiNgA BuRgA Wrote:Firstly, does depend on how important you consider the story.  But you can change things a fair bit with only minor story modifications.  For example, the pacing, drama, emphasis etc can be tweaked to give a nicer effect on some shows I've seen.

Story basically 90% determines whether the show is good or not. You don't see people going around saying "This is an excellent show because it has the best soundtrack ever, even though the plot sucks donkey".

ZiNgA BuRgA Wrote:

Assassinator Wrote:Wee need Tsukihime remake. With Kara no Kyoukai graphics. Then it would be like the best anime ever.

If you're into vampires :P

It (Tsukihime) just had a great story over all, nothing to do with the vampires. Kara no Kyoukai is a 7 part movie series, of which the story is partially linked to Tsukihime (same world, lots of parallels). It has no vampires, only magicians. Now one of them has the story, and the other has production quality far superior to 99% of other anime. Put it together, and you eliminate all the bad points of each.

(This post was last modified: 17/08/2009 06:33 AM by Assassinator.)

Rukia Wrote:

OmegaEye Wrote:

Rukia Wrote:Im just saying i rather liked it,
First music related anime iv seen so far,
So? i can't comment well to anything iv seen previously that's all

try watching Beck
then you'll have something to compare it to

lol i was going to buy beck
But i didnt know if i should or not,

Is it good?

In my opinion, it was quite good
I give at least an 8.5/10

Heartless141 Wrote:why not? have you read the manga?

Admittedly not.

feinicks Wrote:Wee need remakes of and sequels to many anime.....

Mind you - its remakes that made Air and Kanon great.

Assassinator Wrote:Story basically 90% determines whether the show is good or not. You don't see people going around saying "This is an excellent show because it has the best soundtrack ever, even though the plot sucks donkey".

No, but there are plenty of other things to like a show over.
Example I can think of right now, Excel Saga.

Assassinator Wrote:It (Tsukihime) just had a great story over all, nothing to do with the vampires. Kara no Kyoukai is a 7 part movie series, of which the story is partially linked to Tsukihime (same world, lots of parallels). It has no vampires, only magicians. Now one of them has the story, and the other has production quality far superior to 99% of other anime. Put it together, and you eliminate all the bad points of each.

I found the plot fairly average to be honest.

Watched it. It's alright I guess. Good for a lighthearted refreshment, but not something to hit rating charts with. 7/10.

ZiNgA BuRgA Wrote:

Assassinator Wrote:Story basically 90% determines whether the show is good or not. You don't see people going around saying "This is an excellent show because it has the best soundtrack ever, even though the plot sucks donkey".

No, but there are plenty of other things to like a show over.
Example I can think of right now, Excel Saga.

Excel Saga really not a good example with me, as you probably know. I dropped that show on like episode 3, and I hardly ever drop shows. So that puts it at like among the bottom 5 shows out of everything I've watched?

I guess GTO is a good example of what you're trying to express.

I'm gay.

(This post was last modified: 12/09/2009 04:06 PM by ProperBritish.)