Endless Paradigm

Full Version: Mathieulh's opinion on piracy
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Pages: 1 2 3 4
Vegetano1 Wrote:LAME! Erk

but offcourse there is peoples trying to sell riped games,. that's wrong!!
selling is not sharing!

I got plenty of UMD's and 4 PSP's,. if i like a game i will buy it!

PS3 needs to be hacked too!! i had already got 2 games wich i have't used from day 1.

Mathieulh nevar used devhook<? or played a .iso/.cso>?

Isos were allowed on Devhook or M33 because wee were set on a non restrictive policy, wee wanted to let people the choice to load isos for legit uses because:

1.  UMDs have very bad load times.
2. UMDs are noisy
3. UMDs waiste batteries

Notice that wee never hacked the store so you could copy downloaded games out of it or the like.

If you people want to pirate, it is your responsibility but then don't complain when licencees stop releasing good games on the platform because of it. Of course I am not saying that piracy alone is the cause of the bad psp sales, but it does have its part to do with it (how insignificant it might seem compared to other causes such as second hand market or even bad marketing policies from SCE)

If you think the ps3 needs to be hacked, why won't YOU hack it ? (instead of pointlessly complaining.)

I would like people to have some more sense and see the for and against in here, developers also work to provide games and they also do have families to feed.
I believe that pirates also have their arguments but that does not make piracy right.
I also believe that the games prices are way to high especially in the EU, but there are other means to deal with that issue than to pirate all your games.
cboushell Wrote:How the hell do you say his name correctly?  I have to say that I am thankful for his work with the PSP but he sounds like a whiny little sh!t.  He sits there and bitches about piracy which is illegal, but then so is what he did to the security of the PSP anyone ever heard of the DMCA.  I know he isn't in the USA but most countrys now have similar legislation to the DMCA.  Thanks for all of your work with the PSP.

chad

Actually only the USA crappy DMCA forbids software reverse engineering but thank you for your concerns. Thankfully I do not live in the USA, I am therefore not liable to this law (which does not apply to countries in the EU).
:O
mathieulh Wrote:
Vegetano1 Wrote:LAME! Erk

but offcourse there is peoples trying to sell riped games,. that's wrong!!
selling is not sharing!

I got plenty of UMD's and 4 PSP's,. if i like a game i will buy it!

PS3 needs to be hacked too!! i had already got 2 games wich i have't used from day 1.

Mathieulh nevar used devhook<? or played a .iso/.cso>?

Isos were allowed on Devhook or M33 because wee were set on a non restrictive policy, wee wanted to let people the choice to load isos for legit uses because:

1.  UMDs have very bad load times.
2. UMDs are noisy
3. UMDs waiste batteries

Notice that wee never hacked the store so you could copy downloaded games out of it or the like.

If you people want to pirate, it is your responsibility but then don't complain when licencees stop releasing good games on the platform because of it. Of course I am not saying that piracy alone is the cause of the bad psp sales, but it does have its part to do with it (how insignificant it might seem compared to other causes such as second hand market or even bad marketing policies from SCE)

If you think the ps3 needs to be hacked, why won't YOU hack it ? (instead of pointlessly complaining.)

I would like people to have some more sense and see the for and against in here, developers also work to provide games and they also do have families to feed.
I believe that pirates also have their arguments but that does not make piracy right.
I also believe that the games prices are way to high especially in the EU, but there are other means to deal with that issue than to pirate all your games.

sorry i can't hack the PS3 for you,. kidding,. i was just trying to make a point rather then requesting so i was't pointlessy complaining,. ...
I am stuck with 2 games i don't like,. and buying games on the PS3 aint cheap,.. its FAT!!

I don't pirate all my games and i don't think piracy is wrong,.. and does't make it right either.
Also think there are plenty of good games for the PSP>?>? so who is complaining<> i dunno!
PlaystationStore,. NAH!! i don't really like the store!

big part of most happy PSP users ahve cf on there PSP,. if you don't have cf you be missing out on alot of stuff,.. maybe the sales of PSP's went up>?>?

marketing aint always fair trade,..

enough Blablablabla,. and thanks for the bla,. :)

sorry for my bad english Madwin

EDIT: more like: i can't say piracy is wrong,. but does't make it right either,.
EDIT2: thanks for all great work!! Madwin please don't go!!! by the way always thought the PS3 was hacked but nevar released,.. because of sony,.. is this true?
mathieulh Wrote:Isos were allowed on Devhook or M33 because wee were set on a non restrictive policy, wee wanted to let people the choice to load isos for legit uses because:

1.  UMDs have very bad load times.
2. UMDs are noisy
3. UMDs waiste batteries

Notice that wee never hacked the store so you could copy downloaded games out of it or the like.

If you people want to pirate, it is your responsibility but then don't complain when licencees stop releasing good games on the platform because of it. Of course I am not saying that piracy alone is the cause of the bad psp sales, but it does have its part to do with it (how insignificant it might seem compared to other causes such as second hand market or even bad marketing policies from SCE)

If you think the ps3 needs to be hacked, why won't YOU hack it ? (instead of pointlessly complaining.)

I would like people to have some more sense and see the for and against in here, developers also work to provide games and they also do have families to feed.
I believe that pirates also have their arguments but that does not make piracy right.
I also believe that the games prices are way to high especially in the EU, but there are other means to deal with that issue than to pirate all your games.

First of all, welcome to E.P. mathieulh.  It is nice to have such a highly respected dev such as yourself visit our forums  :)

I would like to take a moment to ask you a few questions.

1 - If you guys had such a strong anti piracy stance, but could clearly see the benefits of running games from memory stick, why didn't you implement some sort of protection that would only allow you to rip/play umds if you owned the disc?

2 - Are you guys all done?  If you are I thank you for all you guys did to allow homebrew, and grassroots devs like my to be able to do some developing on the PSP  Madwin    It would be nice if you could give us a little hint, if you guys do got something cooking, even if you don't want to give away too much.

Also, I have 1 more question:  Do you or DAX use any custom themes on your PSP?   If so, what where a few of your favorites?


THANKS FOR READING

~Shizzy
Mr. Shizzy Wrote:
mathieulh Wrote:Isos were allowed on Devhook or M33 because wee were set on a non restrictive policy, wee wanted to let people the choice to load isos for legit uses because:

1.  UMDs have very bad load times.
2. UMDs are noisy
3. UMDs waiste batteries

Notice that wee never hacked the store so you could copy downloaded games out of it or the like.

If you people want to pirate, it is your responsibility but then don't complain when licencees stop releasing good games on the platform because of it. Of course I am not saying that piracy alone is the cause of the bad psp sales, but it does have its part to do with it (how insignificant it might seem compared to other causes such as second hand market or even bad marketing policies from SCE)

If you think the ps3 needs to be hacked, why won't YOU hack it ? (instead of pointlessly complaining.)

I would like people to have some more sense and see the for and against in here, developers also work to provide games and they also do have families to feed.
I believe that pirates also have their arguments but that does not make piracy right.
I also believe that the games prices are way to high especially in the EU, but there are other means to deal with that issue than to pirate all your games.

First of all, welcome to E.P. mathieulh.  It is nice to have such a highly respected dev such as yourself visit our forums  :)

I would like to take a moment to ask you a few questions.

1 - If you guys had such a strong anti piracy stance, but could clearly see the benefits of running games from memory stick, why didn't you implement some sort of protection that would only allow you to rip/play umds if you owned the disc?

2 - Are you guys all done?  If you are I thank you for all you guys did to allow homebrew, and grassroots devs like my to be able to do some developing on the PSP  Madwin    It would be nice if you could give us a little hint, if you guys do got something cooking, even if you don't want to give away too much.

Also, I have 1 more question:  Do you or DAX use any custom themes on your PSP?   If so, what where a few of your favorites?


THANKS FOR READING

~Shizzy

1. Because wee believe in a free non restrictive approach and that adding such a protection would have gone against that policy.

2. As far as I am concerned I am done with the psp platform so far (though I happen to stumble to into it again from time to time.) I don't know what Alex wants to do next on psp or if he plans to come back, he officially did not left at least.

3. Not sure about Alex, but as far as I know wee don't use custom themes on our psps. (I am quite satisfied with the official one so far, though I have not been using my psp much lately)
I thought this post was stupid... So I edited it...
mathieulh Wrote:3. Not sure about Alex, but as far as I know wee don't use custom themes on our psps. (I am quite satisfied with the official one so far, though I have not been using my psp much lately)
the original theme is ok, but it's plain & dull.
the themes people make are amazing, can't believe that ya'll don't use them.

anyways back on topic piracy is some of the problem, but not all.
piracy exist for everything such as movies, music, software & games, yet they still make money & make good products.
Alot of people still buy games, but most aren't worth buying anymore.
I don't mind buying games if there worth it, but since I got the ps3 I quit buying psp games because I don't ever play it.
Hell if it wasn't for themes my psp would just sit & collect dust.
Piracy is wrong but it's not going anywhere & isn't the cause of the psp's downfall.
I know over 20 people with psp's that aren't hacked & I know some with hacked psp's who still buy games.

although I completely understand why you & Dax are done with the PSP ATM, I wish you would reconsider.
either way I appreciate your work & thanks for everything you've done.

@Shizzy excellent question Madwin I always wondered that myself.
ZiNgA BuRgA Wrote:Eh, if you thought it was bad for software, wait until you see the figures for music.
very true the music industry has taken a huge blow because of piracy.

Vegetano1 Wrote:PlaystationStore,. NAH!! i don't really like the store!
I love the Playstation Store, only probably is not enough money to spend there
Nothingface420 Wrote:
ZiNgA BuRgA Wrote:Eh, if you thought it was bad for software, wait until you see the figures for music.
very true the music industry has taken a huge blow because of piracy.
Studies have continually shown that the majority of people who pirate music albums not just buy albums; they but more than most people do. Copyright restrictions and poo poo like MTV kill an artist's chance to become big, but the internet can make them bigger.

And then the greedy record labels take up to 98% of an artist's money, which sometimes amounts to only a few cents an album. I'd rather support a band I like at live concerts, than the record company.

Then again, the record companies are losing something, but not from piracy. They're losing something from not adapting to the digital age.
MysterySword Wrote:Studies have continually shown that the majority of people who pirate music albums not just buy albums; they but more than most people do.

Then again, the record companies are losing something, but not from piracy. They're losing something from not adapting to the digital age.

The question is, how much they buy in proportion to how much they pirate, and you can bet that it'll be a very very small percentage, on average.  Another question is, if they were stopped from pirating, would they buy more or less.

You shouldn't believe every study out there.  Inaccuracies can derive from a lot of areas in such studies.  And depending on the purpose of the creator, they can be crafted in ways that are misleading both to the participants and the viewers (you).

And one of the most basic rules of analysing statistics, relationship does not equate to causation. For example, people in warmer cities tend to have have darker skin color on average, they also eat more ice cream.  You can plot ice cream vs skin color and get a straight line relationship, but does that mean eating ice cream causes you to become black?  Figure that out for yourself (hint: the place is hot).  So these studies are mostly worthless, can you really say piracy causes people to buy more albums?  If you answer no, then piracy is definitely not doing any good for the market but hurting it, and I hope I never meet anyone dumb enough to answer yes.  The situation in your music case would be that most big music lovers both pirate and buy, because they're big music lovers not because piracy makes them buy.  If these pirates were somehow prevented from pirating, they'd probably buy even more CDs.

tl;dr  - Piracy doesn't help the industry.  Never did and never will.

MysterySword Wrote:Copyright restrictions and poo poo like MTV kill an artist's chance to become big, but the internet can make them bigger.

I agree with you on that, the internet capable of making an artist bigger.
Pages: 1 2 3 4
Reference URL's