Endless Paradigm

Is it better to get the lacie bigdisk, or the western digital elements, can anyone provide a review?
EDIT: So I read some reviews, the Lacie seems to be the logical choice, but about 20% of the reviews say it fails after 1 -2 years (has a 3 yr warranty). so i think i will go with that unless someone can provide another option or reason not to.

Edit 2: It appears I will be getting the WD, as the laCie is a 5 hr drive away, and they won't ship it.

Catseye Wrote:Is it better to get the lacie bigdisk, or the western digital elements, can anyone provide a review?
EDIT: So I read some reviews, the Lacie seems to be the logical choice, but about 20% of the reviews say it fails after 1 -2 years (has a 3 yr warranty). so i think i will go with that unless someone can provide another option or reason not to.

Edit 2: It appears I will be getting the WD, as the laCie is a 5 hr drive away, and they won't ship it.

let me know what the elements is like, because i found a buyer for my MyBook Essential hdd, and going on Whirlpool.net to find recommendations for a new one, many have recommended the WD Elements which you bought.

Ok, I will test it on the 9th. One thing people did say was the power supply wasn't perfect, that attributed to what many at first called an hd failure.

Catseye Wrote:Ok, I will test it on the 9th. One thing people did say was the power supply wasn't perfect, that attributed to what many at first called an hd failure.

ah sweet, can't wait to hear how it goes :)

a western digital black would be good. its fast and efficient